14 Best Places To Sell Your Board Games For Profit In 2025

If you're anything like me, you probably have a closet full of board games you've outgrown or lost interest in. Instead of letting them collect dust, why not turn them into a little extra cash?

Plenty of platforms exist to sell board games, and I've compiled a list of the top 13 places to sell your games. 

Whether you're a casual player with a few games to offload or a serious collector looking to pare down your collection, there's a market for you.

Let's dive in and explore some of the best options to turn your group into toys for someone else to enjoy.

Best Places To Sell Your Board Games On Good Price

So, where exactly can you sell your board games? The options are plentiful, and each one has its unique benefits.

From online marketplaces to local shops, there's a place for every type of seller. You might prefer the convenience of online selling, or perhaps you enjoy the face-to-face interaction of a local sale. Here are the places you can sell your board games

eBay

eBay is a tried and trustworthy platform for selling almost anything, including board games. This well-known marketplace allows sellers to reach an enormous and global customer base. With eBay, you can easily create a free seller account and list your games. 

You might be amazed at how many people out there are searching for exactly the game you're ready to part with.

Not only do the current hits sell well here, but vintage board games and collectibles like Pokemon cards also do exceptionally well on eBay. If you've got some old classics lying around, check out their potential value on this platform. 

Remember that eBay charges a 12.35% fee on most product categories, including used board games. However, considering its broad reach and high potential for sales, it's often seen as a fair trade-off.

Noble Knight Games

Next on the list is Noble Knight Games, a trusted platform with a long-standing reputation in the board game industry.

This online marketplace specializes in new and out-of-print games, miniatures, Dungeons and Dragons products, Magic the Gathering cards, and more.

The selling process with Noble Knight is pretty straightforward: you can send them a list of your items, and they'll respond within one or two business days with an offer.

If you accept their offer, they'll cover most shipping costs – plus, their payment options are versatile, including PayPal cash, checks, or store credit.

Just remember that Noble Knight has high standards - your games must be in good condition and free from smoke odors or mold damage.

Garage sales

Garage sales are a classic and straightforward way to offload various items, including board games. This approach works best if you're not just selling one or two games but have a significant collection or other things you want to part with.

The key to a successful garage sale is promoting it well - posting bright, eye-catching flyers around your neighborhood can drum up interest.

Hosting your garage sale on a sunny day won't hurt either! While this might not be my go-to selling strategy, it could work wonders if you want to declutter in one fell swoop.

Alternatively, if you're more interested in refreshing your game assortment than just selling outright, there's eBay.

This clever platform lets you earn points for your old games and trade them in for new ones with the company and other game enthusiasts. For those who always crave something new on game night, BoardGameCo might be the perfect fit.

Amazon FBA

If you're considering selling brand-new board games, Amazon FBA (Fulfillment by Amazon) should be on your list.

This service leverages Amazon's massive e-commerce network and logistics, making it a breeze for sellers to reach a widespread audience. 

To get started, create an Amazon FBA seller account, purchase your board games at a discount from online or physical stores, and send your stock to one of Amazon's fulfillment warehouses. 

For every sale you make, there's a basic charge of $0.99 plus shipping fees and optional services like package preparation.

While these fees might seem discouraging at first, the convenience brought by Amazon in handling everything from shipping to customer service is worth it. 

With Amazon handling the nitty-gritty aspects of the sale process, sellers can focus more on sourcing great deals on board games - another key step in this process - and increasing profits.

Keep your eyes peeled for discounted games at stores like Walmart or Target; these could turn into goldmines when flipped on Amazon FBA!

Geek Market

For all of us self-proclaimed geeks, Geek Market may be our perfect platform. Designed as a marketplace within the BoardGameGeek forum, this platform caters to board game fanatics.

And trust me, selling your board games here is as easy as pie. All you need is to create a free account, verify your email, and you're good to go.

Every listing specifies the game's price, condition, and payment methods. And while PayPal transactions and bank transfers are the norm, communication, and coordination with prospective buyers remain key here. But don't worry about not finding a buyer - the market on Geek Market is expansive!

There are thousands of listings at any given time, with games selling anywhere between $20 to $100. Please note that BoardGameGeek does charge a nominal 3% on sales, but it's a cost-effective option considering the reach - plus, you can always request shipping costs to be covered by the buyer!

Mercari

I have found Mercari to be a fantastic platform for selling board games. This user-friendly app has quickly risen to prominence in the online marketplace space, offering a simple and streamlined approach to sales. Board games fall under their toys and games category, which is popular among buyers.

To start on Mercari, you only need to download the free app and register. You can then list your games easily, adding detailed descriptions and multiple photos to entice potential buyers.

Remember, honesty is always the best policy - accurate information about your game's condition will build trust with buyers.

While you can choose to offer free shipping for your board games sale, it's typically expected that the buyer covers these costs. And one of the reasons I like using Mercari – it only deducts a 10% transaction fee from each sale you make.

Once your game sells, payments are made through direct deposit. Remember that transactions usually take about five business days to go through and reach your account.

Facebook Marketplace

Facebook Marketplace is like a virtual garage sale, and it's one of my favorite places to sell used items, including board games. Transactions take place locally, so there's no need for packaging or shipping.

List your games with a brief description, a clear photo, and the price you want for each. You'll connect directly with interested buyers through Facebook Messenger.

Remember, though, some folks may try to negotiate prices down, while others may express interest and then never follow through.

But despite these occasional frustrations, it's an easy and often successful marketplace for selling those board games you no longer use.

Flea Markets 

Flea Markets are a treasure trove for collectors and hobbyists, which makes them an excellent venue to sell your used board games, significantly if you're offloading an extensive collection or other geek-centric items like collectibles or trading cards alongside your games.

To set up shop at a flea market, you'll need to rent a table - with costs ranging from $100 to $300 based on the market's popularity. 

Nevertheless, this initial investment can pay off due to the steady stream of potential buyers that flea markets attract. It's an excellent way to showcase your collection and make those sales count.

OfferUp

On OfferUp, you can sell your used board games locally and online. Think of it as a platform similar to Facebook Marketplace but specifically focused on various items, including board games.

I've found it easy to make a listing here; setting the price is entirely up to me. Plus, potential buyers can reach out if they have inquiries or intend to negotiate the price. 

For local sales, OfferUp does something fantastic; they have pre-approved meetup spots near busy public areas or even police stations to give everyone an extra sense of security during transactions.

You won't be charged for local commerce, but if you opt for online transactions, you'll see a service fee of $1.99 or 12.9% of the total selling price—whichever is higher.

So, if you're comfortable with Facebook Marketplace but want more options when selling your board games, OfferUp might be your best bet!

Board Game and Hobby Stores

Your local board game and hobby stores can be one of the first places to look into. Although buying collections might be more common in the realm of trading cards and figurines, don't be too quick to overlook these treasure coves- some stores may also purchase board games, especially if they're rare or collector's items. 

However, a word of caution: prepare yourself for potential low offers as these stores need to turn around a profit. Getting your ducks in a row beforehand can lead to a lucrative deal. 

This includes familiarizing yourself with the average manufacturer's suggested retail price (MSRP) of the games you're selling and having a bottom-dollar price in mind. This prior research gives you negotiation power when you meet with potential buyers.

Yard Sales 

Ah, the good old yard sale, a staple of American neighborhoods. It's not just about getting rid of your old clothes or knick-knacks.

More often than not, you'll find board games are a hot commodity at these events. The beauty of yard sales is the immediate transaction - cash in hand and no shipping hassles to worry about!

But it's not all rosy; since it's face-to-face selling, you might find customers haggling for a better deal. Just remember to set a fair price that reflects the game's worth.

It could be worth exploring, especially if you have other items to sell alongside your board games.

Nextdoor

Nextdoor is a neighborhood-focused social platform that provides an excellent opportunity to connect with potential buyers within your local community.

With a strong emphasis on local interactions, Nextdoor allows users to reach out to nearby residents interested in purchasing board games or other items.

It fosters a sense of community, making engaging with like-minded individuals interested in board gaming easier.

Whether selling new or pre-owned games, Nextdoor offers a convenient and efficient way to showcase your collection to a targeted audience, enhancing the chances of finding eager buyers who appreciate your offerings.

Instagram

Instagram provides an excellent platform for board game sellers to connect with potential buyers and showcase their games to a thriving board gaming community.

By utilizing visually engaging posts, sellers can appealingly present their board games, attracting the attention of enthusiasts and collectors.

Using relevant hashtags and engaging with the community through comments and direct messages helps build relationships with potential buyers.

Instagram stories and live sessions also enable real-time interactions, allowing sellers to answer questions and provide more information about the games they offer.

Overall, Instagram offers a dynamic and interactive space to promote board games and establish a strong presence within the board gaming community.

Reddit

Reddit is a valuable platform for board game sellers, with dedicated subreddits such as r/BoardGameExchange catering to the needs of board game enthusiasts looking to buy, sell, or trade games.

These communities provide a focused space where sellers can connect directly with a highly targeted audience.

Sellers can attract potential buyers actively seeking specific board games by posting detailed listings, including game conditions, pricing, and additional information.

Engaging in discussions, responding to inquiries, and participating in trade negotiations further strengthen connections and build trust within the community.

Reddit's board game subreddits offer a convenient and accessible avenue for sellers to reach interested buyers and establish fruitful transactions.

Conclusion

The board game industry is thriving in 2023, and numerous excellent places to sell your board games. The options are diverse and promising, from popular online marketplaces like Amazon and eBay to dedicated board game marketplaces like BoardGameGeek and Bazaar.

Social media platforms, local game stores, and conventions also offer great opportunities for sellers.

Consider fees, shipping options, and customer engagement when choosing a platform. Embrace the dynamic landscape, promote your games effectively, and build a loyal customer base to succeed in this exciting market.